Listen for the pattern: does water run without stopping after a flush, or does the toilet refill briefly even though nobody used it? A fill valve can be replenishing water lost through another component. Identify that path before buying parts. This guide’s tank observations apply to an accessible conventional gravity cistern, not a sealed pressure-assisted or electronic system.
Contain the problem before opening anything
If water is escaping onto the floor, the bowl is rising, or the tank is cracked, stop using the toilet and arrange help. A familiar accessible shutoff can limit incoming water if it operates gently; do not force a seized valve or disconnect a supply while it is live. In a shared or rented property, notify the responsible manager.
Only lift a conventional ceramic tank lid if it can be handled safely. Put it on a protected stable surface. Do not open a sealed pressure vessel, concealed cistern or electrical toilet using instructions for a gravity tank. Find the model information and manufacturer’s service guidance first.
Two different paths can keep the fill valve running
If the water level reaches the overflow, investigate why filling is not stopping at the specified level. If water escapes past a flush seal, the fill valve may restart simply to replace that loss. This is why hearing the fill valve does not by itself prove it is defective. Kohler’s linked guidance distinguishes these paths.
A bounded tank-to-bowl dye check
For a safely accessible conventional gravity tank, and only if the toilet maker permits it, EPA WaterSense describes adding a few drops of food colouring to tank water and checking the bowl after 10 minutes without flushing in between. Colour in the bowl indicates a leak; flush immediately after the check to avoid staining. Do not use this on a blocked/rising bowl, mix it with in-tank chemicals, or open a sealed system.
A positive result identifies tank-to-bowl leakage, not which seal or setting requires repair. Record the visible water path and exact model before selecting a compatible part.
If water keeps entering the overflow
Without dismantling parts, observe whether water is crossing the top of the tank’s overflow tube while filling continues. That differs from water escaping past the flush seal at the bottom. Record the water level relative to the model’s marked fill line and whether any visible control is obstructed.
Kohler’s gravity-toilet guidance distinguishes overflow, binding flush linkage and a worn flapper or canister seal. Use your model’s adjustment instructions, not a universal distance below the tank rim. Do not block the overflow or raise the level to improve flushing.
If the tank refills between uses
Record the interval and look for water entering the bowl without a flush. The fill valve may be doing its job by replacing water that is escaping. A poorly closing flush mechanism, seal or other tank leak needs investigation; the sound alone does not show which part failed.
For a gravity model, a manufacturer-approved dye test can help establish tank-to-bowl leakage if its instructions permit it. Follow the specified method and avoid staining cleaners or improvised additives. A positive test identifies leakage between those areas, not necessarily the precise failed gasket. Visible water outside the tank requires a separate leak assessment.
If the handle or button does not return normally
Note whether the problem started after a lid was moved, a button was fitted or a flush part was replaced. A held-open flush mechanism can resemble a bad seal. Check only visible interference allowed by the manual; do not bend a lever or trim button rods by guesswork.
Flapper chains, canister mechanisms, dual-flush buttons and concealed controls have different requirements. If adjustment is a suitable owner task, isolate the supply as directed and follow the exact component instructions. If fit, access or isolation is uncertain, have a plumber correct it. Repeated handle-jiggling is a symptom to report rather than a completed repair.
If it began after replacement or cleaning
Keep the toilet model and installed part number. Confirm compatibility, required settings and refill-tube arrangement with the manufacturer. A part advertised as universal may still require a model-specific setting or may not suit this flush valve. Do not push a refill tube deeper or add weights to a seal to silence running.
Report any in-tank cleaning product used and when the fault began. Follow the toilet and component maker’s cleaning restrictions. Servicing a fill valve requires its own isolation and disassembly instructions; instructions for one brand should not be used on another.
Verify both shutoff and normal flushing after repair
Once safe work is complete, confirm the tank stops filling at its specified level and does not restart between uses. Check the supply connection and tank exterior for fresh water after ordinary flushing. Do not leave a newly adjusted or replaced assembly unattended until its behavior has been checked.
If running returns, provide the previous part, adjustment and observed water path to the plumber. If the toilet also flushes weakly, use the weak-flush guide; correcting leakage should not leave the model with the wrong fill or flush setting.



